Quarterly/September 2006
These articles are free but cost money to make, so please
make a donation and help us with the production costs.
Editorial
Legal victory
Long struggle against
endosulfan poisoning
wins relief in India 3
In India, the government of Kerala State has announced relief and
remediation to a community whose health has been badly damaged by
endosulfan spraying. The Chief Minister of the State has promised to
bring companies responsible for the homicide to justice. Jayakumar
Chelaton and R Sridhar of Thanal, the group supporting those affected,
report on developments.
Health
Foetal exposure –
leaving an unwelcome
legacy 4
Pesticides have been shown to interfere with a range of vital
processes during the development of the human foetus. Chlorpyrifos
can cause intra-uterine-growth-retardation, a condition which results
in low birth weight and has serious consequences for later life.
Dithiocarbamates have been shown to interfere with thyroid
hormones and glucocorticoids which can lead to conditions such as
high blood pressure. Professor Janna Koppe explains.
Risk assessment
Current risk assessment
fails to protect children 6
Current pesticide risk assessment protocols at best allow for the
possibility that children may be up to ten times more sensitive to
pesticides than adults. However, a recent study indicates they may be
up to 164-fold more sensitive to the effects of organophosphates.
These results call into question current procedures to protect our
children. We interviewed Professor Asa Bradman, one of the authors
of this study.
European regulation
EU groundwater
protection at risk 8
A proposed new Groundwater Directive for Europe is currently being
discussed. Despite the importance of groundwater, and the failure of the
current Groundwater Directive to protect it, the EU institutions could
not agree on far-reaching protection requirements. Council, influenced
by the UK and Dutch governments, has rejected a clear pollution
prevention approach and exempted agriculture from quality standards,
while the European Parliament insists on prevention but introduced
some new loopholes. By end of this year both will have to achieve an
agreement. Stefan Scheuer reports.
UK government rejects
recommendations to
protect public health 9
In July this year, the government published its response to the Royal
Commission on Environmental Pollution’s report ‘Crop Spraying and
the health of residents and bystanders’. Campaigners have been
shocked by the government’s flat rejection of the major
recommendations. Clare Butler Ellis gives PAN UK’s reaction.
New EU legislation
finally adopted 10
After long delays, the European Commission has adopted proposals
for two new pieces of legislation that will set the scene for future
pesticide regulation. In spite of some positive elements, the draft
Directive does not go far enough towards pesticide use reduction,
while the draft Regulation for approvals may see some replacement of
riskier pesticides. Sofia Parente reports on the next steps.
France’s new pesticide plan will
not significantly reduce use 11
Community action
Drift Catcher reveals
unacceptable levels of
chlorpyrifos in air 12
In July of this year the first public announcement of results from the
Drift Catcher was made. Air samples collected and analysed in
Lindsay, California during the summers of 2004 and 2005 showed
that air concentrations of the insecticide chlorpyrifos frequently
exceeded the acute and sub-chronic Reference Exposure Level for
children. These results are being used by local community groups to
support their demands for no-spray zones between residential and
sprayed areas. Brian Hill of the Pesticide Action Network North
America reports.
Obsolete stockpiles
South African waste
study highlights need
for prevention work 14
In South Africa in 1997 a national retrieval project was operated to
collect and dispose of obsolete pesticide stocks. However, many farms
which disposed of waste pesticides at that time have since reaccumulated
more. This situation underscores the need for strategies
to reduce pesticide use to prevent future stockpiles. Leslie London,
Mohamed Aqiel Dalvie, and Algenon Africa describe the situation.
Developing country initiatives
Foreign donors help
small ACP growers meet
European standards 16
Without the help of foreign donors small-scale growers in African,
Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) countries would no longer be able to
export their produce because of their inability to meet the costs of
complying with commercial standards requested by European
importers. The Pesticide Initiative Programme reports here on its
activities to give ACP smallholders a fairer chance in European
markets.
Better health, more
wealth: the impacts of
farmer training in
developing countries 18
Concern over high rates of pesticide poisoning in developing countries
have prompted restrictions on the export of the most hazardous pesticides
and the development of farmer training programmes to promote
integrated pest management. Professor Homi Katrak provides an
overview of the situation and examines the impact of Farmer Field
Schools. Data from four countries show impressive increases in farmers’
rate of financial return after field school training. Health gains have not
been formally documented, and he proposes some first steps in developing
a method for quantifiying such gains.
Bt cotton growers in China lose
money due to secondary pests 21
EPA bans lindane 21
News and resources
22
Obituary – Sunil
Kumar Verma, Bhopal
Wearing organic cotton has never been easier
Two poisoned by paraquat in UK
Book reviews 23
New health and safety
resource
Organic cotton supports
African development
Pesticide impacts in
South Korea
Agroecology and food
sovereignty