The publication of Our
Stolen Future (see PN 31
p6) has fuelled the debate as to whether synthetic chemicals have effects on
human reproductive system by causing disruption of the endocrine system.
Written primarily by Theo Colborn of the World Wildlife Fund in the US, the
book follows and assesses a whole range of diverse research which has
identified disruptions in the breeding cycles on numerous animals, from fish
and birds to otters and whales. These were accompanied by increases in birth
defects, sexual abnormalities, and reproductive failure. The effects have
been linked to the presence in the environment of chemicals, such as
pesticides such as DDT and lindane, that mimic natural hormones and trick
the reproductive system. Theo Colborn has also examined the effects on
humans. Male sperm counts have dropped as much as 50% in recent decades, and
women have seen a dramatic rise in hormone-related cancers.
The book has
generated many reviews and comments. Some are describing it as the most
important analysis of environmental pollution since Rachel Carson's Silent
Spring, The New York Times
has not been so generous describing the work as unscientific. This
may have more to do with the format of the Our
Stolen Future which is at times is chatty, and always informative to the
lay reader. Nevertheless, the science on which it is based is well founded.
The chemical industry has also rejected Colborn's claims, stating that the
hypothesis is very controversial. However, industry is concerned enough to
fund research into this whole topic.
Our Stolen Future, Theo Colborn, John Peterson Myers and Dianne Dumanoski, Little Brown, £18.95, 304pp.
[This article first appeared in Pesticides News No. 32, June 1996, page 15]