PAN International Website

Alternatives to pesticides workshop

The Alternatives to Pesticides Day was held at Barham Park in Brent in October. Forty-five people attended the workshop representing local authorities, the retail sector, suppliers of alternative controls, the Greater London Authority and the Crop Protection Association.

Workshop presentations covered the work of PAN UK, the Green Flag Park Awards, microbial turf treatments, the latest aquacide machine, non-chemical weed control on hard surfaces, Brent’s organic status at Fryent Country Park, the London Borough of Southwark’s pesticide reduction policy, new NPTC testing, the Greater London Authority’s environment strategy and the impact of pesticides on water quality. 

Non-chemical control
Two microbial turf treatments were looked at: one developed in the US and the other developed in the UK using native mycorrhiza. Microbial inoculation is recommended for treating soils where mycorrhiza are absent, for example, sand based golf courses, sterilised/fumigated soils and artificial growing media. 
    In response to pesticide taxes in Canada Smithco has developed the latest steam machine for killing weeds on hard surfaces. Water heated to 280oC applied at low-pressure kills vegetation on contact. Two sizes of machine can be mounted on a broad range of trucks and trailers. The machine does not require the user to have a Certificate of Competence for the UK and is safe to use near people, pets and to the environment. It can be used in all weathers and does not present the danger of water contamination. The versatile machinery can be used on hard surfaces and around existing planting in a wide range of locations; golf courses, parks, driveways and roadside verges. Machines are diesel powered and a 400 litre water tank on maximum power works for 1hour and 10 minutes. 
    A research project funded by the Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions to look into non-chemical weed control on hard surfaces was completed in June 2000. The project examined the cost effectiveness of minimum input organic and integrated systems. The environmental and health benefits of pesticide minimisation must be addressed in terms of alternative methods, which may be more labour intensive. Councils now have greater flexibility to choose an expensive technique over the cheapest treatments under ‘Best Value’ policies.

Fryent Country Park
The organic status achieved by Brent parks management marks an important achievement. Leslie Williams said that conversion was completed after two years and the park’s activities include hay production and orchard and woodland plots. Creeping thistle, the main problem weed, has been successfully controlled by an additional cut after hay removal. A reduction of 90% of the weed infestation has been achieved by cutting three times a year; the first cut in the spring, a second in June or July followed by a third in late summer/early August. Pesticides used in wood treatments have also been reduced by using recycled plastic park furniture, fencing, rights of way markers and untreated tree stakes. Heat treatment has been successful for weed control on hard surfaces on a small scale. No insecticides are used on roses as only stock resistant to disease is purchased. 

Southwark
The London Borough of Southwark developed their Pesticide Reduction Policy with PAN UK in 1996. The Policy prohibits the use of pesticides that can harm the environment, especially water, and seeks to remove the risk of exposure to such pesticides to those who live and work in Southwark. The success of the policy implementation has been recognised by the Green Apple Award received by Southwark this year and by the pesticide reduction illustrated by monitoring records.

Residues in water
Privatisation of UK water companies coincided with the implementation of the Water Supply Regulations 1989. PCVs (prescribed concentrations or values) are stated for each parameter for the protection of public health and aesthetic value. The standards are 0.1 microgram/litre of an individual substance/pesticide or 0.5 micrograms/litre as a total value. The length of time a pollutant remains in a receptor (river/borehole) depends upon a number of factors. Rivers may be affected by short-term duration and variable concentration but are potentially predictable in terms of rainfall or spillage incidents. Groundwater presents a longer term problem, concentrations are more stable and the reduction or removal of pollutants relies on replenishment of water in the aquifer.

Feedback
Discussion groups in the afternoon session addressed pesticide reduction issues relating to the general public, staff and contractors, council structure and finance. Although reduction can be hampered by these factors the group felt that the process could be promoted through effective training and education targeted at the general public, staff and contractors and elected council members. 
    Feedback from the group highlighted the benefit of talking to colleagues from other councils and organisations and noted the good quality presentations and handouts. It was suggested that practical demonstrations of products would be useful and further information about the external costs of pesticide use would be helpful. Participants requested that the meeting in London be scheduled at the same time next year and that local workshops take place to reduce the need to travel. Some participants would also be willing to attend a workshop over a longer period to allow for more in depth discussion and analysis of the issues raised. (AW)

The next workshop will be held in the Leicester and Coventry area in March 2001 and will focus on public health issues. Those interested in participating in this and future workshops should contact Alex Williams at PAN-UK by telephone on 020 7274 8895 or by e-mail at alexwilliams@pan-uk.org for further information.

New project name for PAN UK 
The Local Authorities Project has worked with many local authorities since 1992 and is now being developed to incorporate other organisations that use non-agricultural pesticides. To reflect the broadening scope of the project we are changing the name to Local Action on Pesticides.

[This article first appeared in Pesticides News No.50, December 2000, p19]


Subscriptions
Publications
Email the Editor