Doctors’ health warning 

Canadian doctors have completed their biggest-ever analysis of the effects of chemicals on people. Their report makes disturbing reading.

Doctors in Ontario, Canada, are urging people to avoid any contact with common household pesticides. Links between the pesticides and foetal defects, neurological damage and most deadly cancers are strong enough to prompt the warning, said the Ontario College of Family Physicians.
    They released the most comprehensive study ever done in Canada on the chronic effects of pesticide exposure at home, in the garden and at work. ‘The review found consistent evidence of the health risks to patients with exposure to pesticides,’ said the study.
    College researchers also found consistent links between parents’ exposure to certain agricultural pesticides in their jobs and effects on the growing foetus ranging from damage to death. They concluded there were risks from food residues, ant sprays and pet collars.
    Children are far more vulnerable to the effects of pesticides than adults because, as they grow, they have a greater skin surface in proportion to their size, they ingest more food for their size and they often have less developed ways of excreting chemicals.
    After examining 12,000 studies organised between 1990 and 2003 from across the world and pairing them down to the 250 most significant, the researchers found there was no evidence that some pesticides are less dangerous than others – they just have different effects on health that show over varying time scales.
    ‘People need to think long and hard before they take the risk for themselves, their children and their grandchildren of having a golf-green lawn,’ said Cathy Vakil, of the Family Medicine Centre at Queen’s University in Kingston and one of the report’s authors. She noted that pesticides used in Toronto’s 200,000 storm sewers to kill mosquito larvae have retinoid as a breakdown product – a family of chemicals which causes limb deformities in foetuses. This is washed into Lake Ontario and, in turn, in the drinking water of the Greater Toronto Area.

Huron County Federation of Agriculture (HCFA) and the Globe and Mail, 24 April , 2004. The full report is available at: http://www.ocfp.on.ca/

[This article first appeared in Pesticides News No. 64, June 2004, page 15]