In the 1990s, increasing awareness of health problems experienced by sheep
farmers led to reductions in the use of organophosphates for sheep dipping. An
unfortunate side effect was increased use of the synthetic pyrethroid
cypermethrin. Cypermethrin is around a thousand times more toxic to
invertebrates and large quantities are used in sheep dipping. There are numerous
points in this process when spills, leaks and drips from dipped sheep can pollute
rivers and fields. Buglife, a charity focusing on invertebrate biodiversity, has
drawn attention to this outmoded and polluting practice, and has achieved a
temporary suspension of the use of cypermethrin for sheep dipping (
page 3).
A controversy has been brewing in the United States (US) over the use of
human dosing studies by agrochemical companies. Although such studies are
carried out in the US, a moratorium has prohibited the US Environmental
Protection Agency from considering them as part of a pesticide registration
package. This moratorium was lifted in April of this year. In this issue we review
these developments and consider the ethical implications, and the motivation of
companies conducting such studies. Although human dosing studies are not
required to register a pesticide in Europe it is legal to conduct such studies and
they will be considered if submitted to regulators as part of a registration
package (page 6).
The role of pesticides in the development of certain chronic health problems
remains controversial. In this issue we carry an article reviewing evidence that
pesticide exposure may be involved in the development of prostate cancer, non-
Hodgkin’s lymphoma, testicular cancer and childhood cancers. The authors
conclude by arguing for greater precaution in the licensing and use of chemicals
such as pesticides (page 12). A second article reviews multiple chemical
sensitivity (MCS), a condition whose biological basis is recognised in countries
such as Germany and Australia, but which is still not recognised in the UK. The
author argues for recognition of MCS as an illness and discusses evidence that
chemicals such as pesticides may have a role in its aetiology (page 9).
We have frequently reported on problems caused by large stockpiles of
obsolete pesticides in Africa. An integral part of the solution is to ensure that,
once current stockpiles are removed, future
stockpiles are not allowed to accumulate.We
report on a project in Mozambique identifying the
historic reasons for stockpile accumulation and
work to prevent this problem arising again (page
18).
One of the unavoidable consequences of
pesticide use is the generation of hazardous waste
most frequently in the form of empty pesticide
containers. Tens of thousands of tonnes of such
waste is generated every year. In developing
countries empty containers often find secondary uses most notoriously for
carrying drinking water and sometimes with catastrophic effect. It is essential that
pesticides are managed throughout their whole lifecycle and schemes for
managing pesticide containers safely and sustainably are a vital part of this.
Technical and financial considerations in establishing such schemes are reviewed
along with examples of successful schemes (page 16).